CCTP695:  American Popular Culture: History, Story & Analysis

 Fall 2005   

 [ Log In ]  [ CNDLS Poster Tool Home ]  [ Poster Listing]
 

Spike Lee's Bamboozled (2000) and Black Masculinity and Visual Culture by Herman Gray

Dalia Sadiq

"You've been hoodwinked. You've
been had. You've been took.
You've been led astray, run amok.
You've been bamboozled."

untitled.jpeg

Opening Questions for Discussion

  1. What do you believe the main message is in Spike Lee's movie Bamboozled (2000)?
  2. What are some of the ways that Bamboozled explores identity as a system of signs and set of performances? How is identity performed? What are some of the indications of this, such as naming, language, masks, icons and arts?
  3. How does the film Bamboozled make use of the cultural past? What is the role of material objects of history? What role(s) do the "black collectibles", for example, play in the film? What are the other ways that the cultural past is invoked and used as part of the film's critical logic? Think about this, would you buy a racial collectible from an antique store today?
  4. Are the racist commentaries presented in the film supposed to take on, in your opinion, a source of pain for the viewer or a source of healing? What do these messages try to invoke?
  5. Why would Lee chose to use an African American to dress in "blackface" instead of the historical use of White Americans using "blackface" in minstrel shows to portray "Blacks"? What are his intentions in doing this?
  6. Lee seems to make a clear statement critiquing the status of African Americans today in society throughout the film which poses important questions: Does mainstream acceptance of African American actors and entertainers depend on the stereotypical white definition of blackness? Must African American culture remain mired in images of promiscuity and criminality for white consumption?
  7. General question: How did you feel while watching this movie? What was your reaction to film?


 Spike Lee's Bamboozled (2000) Summary:

           In Bamboozled, Spike Lee reconstructs a blackface minstrelsy, in which he addresses social and political comments about race, identity negotiation and politics. This is done through the representation of pivotal characters such as Pierre Delacroix, Tavis and Manray. Delacroix, a Harvard educated African American is a television producer for CNS, who has had his creative ideas for a show constantly rejected. These shows are ones that portray African Americans in a respectible light. Delacroix is put under pressure from his boss Dunwitty (who claims to be blacker than him) to produce an entertaining "black show" or he will be fired.  

        Faced with an ultimatum of either coming up with a hit black-centric show for the network or being fired, Delacroix opts for the latter on the basis that being fired will free him from his contract to the network and allow him to go to work for another network without having to go through the hassle of quitting and being sued for breach of contract. Delacroix decides to pitch a minstrel show for the Millennium, "Mantan's New Millennium Minstrel Show complete with black actors in blackface, Mantan (Manray) and Sleep n Eat (Womack). He does this on the belief that the network would reject it for being outright racist and fire him on the spot. However, Dunwitty surprisingly loves the idea and later Delacroix with its national success embraces his work and defends it as purely satirical work instead of an offensive one.

        Bamboozled's narrative, through the network decision to air this minstrel show, suggests the dangers implicit in re-presenting the damaging humor and stereotypes that inform minstrelsy's discourse and the extent to which satire can be used as a suspicious excuse for promoting racist ideology. The film, in turn, can be seen as a critique of modern attempts to apologize for and justify the repetition of traditional racist stereotyping in the modern mass entertainment industry.

"Spike Lee's answer to ''Network'' is a scaldingly funny satire of the television industry in which a failing network hits the ratings jackpot with an old-time black minstrel show that resurrects offensive stereotypes. Accepted as hip, ironic and liberating by mainstream audiences but reviled by black militants, it starts a national craze for wearing blackface. If this messy cinematic collage goes every which way, its anger at a television industry that largely excludes blacks and whose black programming (in the director's view) perpetuates minstrelsy is right on target." (Holden NY Times Review) 

Herman Gray's Article, Black Masculinity and Visual Culture

     This article explores the social circumstances and cultural conditions in which contemporary representations of black masculinity are produced and circulated to reveal the formal and largely constructed ways of seeing and understanding visual representations of black masculinity. Gray quotes Gerald Early in his article, stating "self-representation of black masculinity in the United States are historically structured by and against dominant (and dominating) discourses of masculinity, and race, specifically (whiteness)." (1)

 


Bamboozled's movie Trailer Link

Minstrel and Blackface Historical Posters

Minstrel_PosterBillyVanWare.jpg

"Billy Van, The Monologue Comedian"

Source and information

Coon.jpg

All Coons Look Alike To Me, by the black songwriter Ernest Hogan, 1890s

Brief History of Blackface and Minstrel Shows

Modern Day Blackface:

Modern Day Blackface.jpeg

Source

       I believe that Spike Lee may see this cartoon as a valid criticism of today's "blackface", an evolved Minstrel Show that reinforces stereotypes of African Americans. These stereotypes include among many, violence, stealing, fascination with material wealth, etc.. This is what sells, just as Minstrel Shows sold, selling the image of African Americans as a people to fear and fantasize about to the white market. If one was to explore the Rap Music industry, this view would be confirmed, there may be many rappers whom perpetuate non-violence and other principles of moral, however this is not what sells. The culture industry looks for profit and these images are key to selling.

This image bellow of 50 Cent is considered by many critiques the epitome of the concept of "Modern Blackface", 50 Cent's records sell in the millions. However, aren't they also selling and reaffirming racial stereotypes?

50 cent.jpeg

Source

 

The-N Word: An Overview by TRIO Television, 3 minute clip

Easily the most inflammatory word in the English language, the 'n' word has smoldered in the American psyche for over a century. From minstrel shows reinforcing racial stereotypes to Richard Pryor bringing the word to the mainstream, TRIO explores the history of the word and how it has been used over the years

Different Uses of The N-Word Today

Also on a different note, it is interesting to see the evolution of the n-word today to be used against Arabs and Muslims. Today "Sand Nigger" and "Dune Nigger" are used in the same derogatory manner. Definitions of Sand Nigger in the Urban Dictionary Online

Historical Racist Black Collectibles

collectible.jpg

Blackface collectible used in Bamboozled  Source


Readings & Course

Use of Adorno and Horkheimer's The Culture Industry: Enlightenment as Mass Deception

In Adorno and Horkheimer's The Culture Industry: Enlightenment as Mass Deception, they describe the cultural industry as one that is driven by solely financial interests rather than mass cultural interests. In this essay they describe laughter according to mass media and the culture industry by stating, "To laugh at something is always to deride it...Such a laughing audience is a parody of humanity. Its members are nomads, all dedicated to pleasure of being ready for anything at the expense of everyone else. (17)

This could be applied in Bamboozled; Lee looks at the culture industry as such, by the show becoming successful and accepted, the network then becomes a parody of the culture industry. These stereotypes are what sell in Bamboozled's minstrel show "Mantan: The New Millennium Minstrel Show" and in African American characters today in the entertainment industry. Lee is critiquing the idea of racism inherent and essential to the success of the culture industry, at the cost of people.

Bamboozled's criticism of the television and the culture industry is focused on the issue of satire. "This form is disingenuously invoked by the network (and sometimes by Delacroix) to justify the show, the real purpose of which is not effect social change but to make money off jokes that reinforce mass entertainment for the securing of white privilege."  (Epp 4)

Applying James Scott-Voices under Domination: The Arts of Political Disguise

Bamboozled is a political disguise used by Lee to comment on the continuing struggle of African Americans to dispel notions of prejudice against them that are perpetuated in the entertainment industry. Lee uses the Minstrel Show as a Euphemism or as the concept of the World Upside Down ( in that there is no possible way that society would accept a ministrel show today) to create this resistance. It is automatically understood as Blatant resistance by many educated viewers from the beginning of the movie, however many will not understand the message till the middle of the movie when protesters are protesting against such a show. This movie is what Scott would consider to be a form of resistance taken forth by a subordinate group, in this disguised manner (using the minstrel show) into the public transcript.


Exploring the Cultural Artifcat

  • Blackness defined in the Culture Industry through Bamboozled,  Examples in the Movie
  • The use of Satire and Parody in the Film Analysis
  • Brief reviews by the critics of the nation. Reviews
  • The Term "Bamboozled" and its use Analysis
  • Scenes of applying Blackface More...
  • Other Scenes described and analyzed of Mantan's Minstrel Show Analysis
  • Was this movie effective in its message?


Articles and Books used in Presentation:

  • Powell, Gerald A. A Rehtoric of Symbolic Identity: An Analysis of Spike Lee's X and Bamboozled. Oxford: University Press of America, 2004.
  • Epp, Micheal H. "Raising Minstrelsy: Humor, Satire and the Stereotype in The Birth of a Nation and Bamboozled. Canadian Review of American Studies, Issue 33:1, 2003.

Further Sources and Reading in regards to this Presentation:

  • Bamboozled: The Movie's Official Website: this website has clips from the movie, clips from old animated minstrel shows, history of blackface and minstrel shows and many more interesting features pertaining to the movie.  http://www.bamboozledmovie.com/ 
  • Lucia, Cynthia. A Critical Symposium on Spike Lee's "Bamboozled", 2001. Cineaste, Volume 26, 2001.
  • Crowdus, Gary and Dan Georakas. "Thinking about Power of Images: An Interview with Spike Lee.", Cineaste 26:2, 2001.
  • Bamboozled full script is online: http://www.awesomefilm.com/script/Bamboozled.txt
 


 

 

This tool is based on an original model developed by the Knowledge Media Lab of the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching.
Questions? Email the webmaster.
Problems? Report an Error.